City Mission Society Inc
Donations deductibleRevenue
$9.4m
year to 30 September 2025
Expenses
$9.7m
year to 30 September 2025
Total assets
$26.8m
$7.2m liabilities
Net assets
$19.6m
assets less liabilities
Directors and trustees
11
6.4y av
Staff
106
5,309 volunteers
Left since last filing
0
no seats appear to have opened
Officers and senior staff
6
named in Part VII
City Mission Society Inc's network
11 people3 organisationsi11 people and 3 organisations on this map.The large node is the subject of this page. Solid lines are what the register itself records (11). Violet dotted lines (3) are likely: the same full name sits on the current board of another organisation in the same register and region. Form 990 filings give names without a person identifier; SEC insider filings carry a CIK. It may be a different person.The board
11 listediTime on the board is observed from the annual filings: the IRS files no appointment date, so the bar counts years from the first filing the person appears on - a lower bound, not a filed start date. Names are exactly as filed. The IRS publishes no person identifier, so this edition does not yet link a person across organisations in the tables. The network map shows same-name matches as likely links only, never as confirmed.Tenure and departures are observed across annual filings. Observed tenure is a lower bound - a member may have joined before the first year on record. The organisation reported 9 voting members of its governing body on its latest Form 990 Part VI, which matches the board listed here.| Name | Role as filed | Since | On the board |
|---|---|---|---|
| Craigg McRae | Board Member/(Treasurer From 1/1/24) | 2021 | 5 yrs |
| Elizabeth Wright | Board Member (Began 9/28/23) | 2024 | 2 yrs |
| Grace Huff | Board Member/(President From 1/1/24) | 2018 | 8 yrs |
| Joel Terragnoli | Board Member/(Secretary From 1/1/24) | 2018 | 8 yrs |
| John Pieroni | Board Member (Term 12/31/23) | 2018 | 8 yrs |
| Matt Bissett | Board Member (Began 3/28/24) | 2024 | 2 yrs |
| Melody Rutherford | Board Member | 2019 | 7 yrs |
| Pastor Jeffery Bowens | Board Member (Began 3/1/24) | 2024 | 2 yrs |
| Paul Kazmierczak | Board Member/Presid (Term 12/31/23) | 2018 | 8 yrs |
| Schuyler Banks | Board Member | 2018 | 8 yrs |
| Sharlene Buszka | Board Member/(VP From 1/1/24) | 2018 | 8 yrs |
Officers and senior leadership
6 listediNamed in Part VII as officers, key employees or highest-compensated staff - not board members, shown for completeness.| Name | Title as filed | On the filings |
|---|---|---|
| Amy Thew | Chief Financial Officer | since 2020 |
| Aubrey Calhoun | Executive Director/CEO (Term 4/22/25) | since 2022 |
| Mark Nigro | CFO (To April, 2019) | since 2018 |
| Salvatore Durante | Chief Program Officer | since 2023 |
| Stuart Harper | Executive Director (To May 22) | since 2018 |
| Yvonne Banks | Chief Operating Officer | since 2021 |
Pay and hours
year to 30 September 2025iFrom Part VII of the Form 990: compensation reported for each officer, director, trustee, key employee and highest-paid staff member, and the average hours a week they report. Most board members are unpaid; a blank means nothing was reported. Pay from related organisations is shown separately.| Name | Title as filed | Hours a week | Pay from the organisation | Related organisations | Other |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aubrey Calhoun | Executive Director (To 4/22/25) | 40 | $147k | $19k | |
| Marilyn Forcucci | Interim CEO/COO/Ed (From 4/23/25) | 40 | $107k | ||
| Brian Majchrowicz | Controller | 40 | $44k | $3k | |
| Schuyler Banks | Board Member | 1 | $0 | ||
| Melody Rutherford | Board Member | 1 | $0 | ||
| Pastor Jeffery Bowens | Board Member | 1 | $0 | ||
| Matt Bissett | Board Member | 1 | $0 | ||
| Elizabeth Wright | Board Member | 1 | $0 | ||
| Grace Huff | Board Member/President | 1 | $0 | ||
| Paul Kazmierczak | Board Member | 1 | $0 | ||
| Joel Terragnoli | Board Member/Secretary | 1 | $0 | ||
| Craigg McRae | Board Member/Treasurer | 1 | $0 | ||
| Sharlene Buszka | Board Member/Vice President | 1 | $0 | ||
| Mark Nigro | Board Member (From 11/19/24) | 1 | $0 | ||
| Lisa Foti | Board Member (From 1/30/25) | 1 | $0 |
About
- Legal name
- City Mission Society Inc
- EIN
- 160743965
- Address
- 100 E Tupper St, Buffalo, NY, 14203-1315
- State
- New York
- Mission
- (as filed on the Form 990)
- Activity (NTEE)
- P200 Human services
- IRS classification
- 501(c)03 (tax-exempt under section 501(c)(3) where shown)
- Classified purpose
- Human Services
- Size band
- 8 (IRS master file code)
- Formed
- 1917
- Principal officer
- Marilyn Forcucci (as named on the Form 990)
- IRS ruling date
- 1 January 1947
- Status
- Code 01 (unconditional exemption)
- Form 990 filings on record
- 7, latest 2024
- IRS Publication 78
- PC (contributions deductible)
Most connected
Longest observed on the filings
≥8years on the filingsGrace Huff
≥8years on the filingsJoel Terragnoli
≥8years on the filingsJohn Pieroni
≥8years on the filingsPaul Kazmierczak
Latest return
year to 30 September 2025iFigures from the newest Form 990 or 990-EZ in the IRS e-file releases of 2025 and 2026, for the year ending 30 September 2025. US dollars, as filed.- Total assets
- $26.8m
- Total liabilities
- $7.2m
- Net assets or fund balances
- $19.6m
- Contributions and grants received
- $8m
- Program service revenue
- $1.1m
- Grants and similar paid out
- $759k
- Employees
- 106
- Volunteers
- 5,309
Filed finances
1 yeariTotals as filed on the IRS Form 990 (revenue and expenses), by tax year.| Tax year | Total revenue | Total expenses | Surplus or deficit |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | $9.5m | $10.1m | Deficit $641k |
As filed on the IRS Form 990. US dollars.